Digs Realty Fall Update

Fall Market Update
Good morning friends. This year’s fall market has, unfortunately, been relatively lackluster.  Early fall is typically the second busiest period in NYC residential real estate, but this year, we are feeling the pain of the high interest rates plaguing residential real estate markets nationwide.  Manhattan inventory is down roughly 10% from 2025’s fall market and liquidity is down approximately 8% year-over-year.  In most Manhattan and Brownstone Brooklyn submarkets, we are in a scarcity market for housing consumers.  Buyers have very little inventory to choose from and often find themselves bidding against multiple interested parties for properties that, in a more evenly-supplied market, would have been less popular.  The rental market alternative for consumers is even more depressing, as we continue to see materially higher year-over-year rent increases across high demand submarkets throughout the city.  This has created an attractive environment for sellers and landlords, and prices are climbing.

Housing consumers find themselves with a dilemma at the moment – scour the sales market for a diamond in the rough among the lackluster supply, and swallow the bitter pill of high interest rates and rising carrying costs, or pay absurd rents to a landlord for what is often an inferior product.  This depressing set of circumstances has kept would-be sellers in their apartments longer than they want and continues to be part of the reason why in-demand neighborhoods are undersupplied, creating a cycle that is difficult to break. 
Early Insights on the Pied-a-Terre Tax 
As discussed at length in our prior newsletter, a real estate tax surcharge on part-time New York City residences worth around $5M and up was implemented this past July.  The “Pied-a-Terre Tax”, aka the “Mamdani Tax”, was cheered by many of Mayor Mamdani’s “tax the rich” acolytes in the city’s more progressive-leaning precincts and jeered by many in the real estate community as bad policy that was likely going to reduce NYC’s tax base, generate far less than the promised $500M in annual revenue and deplete the high end of the city’s real estate market.  The tax has also been the subject of several lawsuits working their way through the courts since its problematic rollout.  One early judicial defeat, which called for the City to essentially start over from scratch and re-implement the entire program, was reversed on appeal and, for the time being, the tax remains in effect.  

As a married couple and business partners, Dan and Rebecca never ever disagree on anything, but we did have diverging thoughts on the impact that the pied-a-terre tax was going to have on the market.  Dan was of the opinion that the resilience of the NYC market will essentially shrug off the tax, while Rebecca took a more nuanced view.  She predicted an increase in $5-$10M condo listings, with pied-a-terre owners at that price point looking to pivot to either less expensive inventory or leave the NYC market entirely, as well as greater downward pressure on pricing in $5-$6M condo inventory with fewer pied-a-terre buyers willing to pay the tax.  

So, what has happened to the $5M+ market since July?  

We have received calls from frustrated high-end pied-a-terre owners asking about the tax and contemplating a sale, we have had pied-a-terre buyers modify their budgets so they won’t be hit with the tax, and we have spoken to pied-a-terre buyers with budgets well below $5M who were misinformed about whether they would be subject to the tax.    

Despite these conversations, there has not been a surge in expensive condo listings from pied-a-terre owners (much to the dismay of many of our high-end buyers), nor has there been a surge in expensive condo rental listings from pied-a-terre owners who want to avoid the tax.  In the 4+ months since the tax went into effect, the number of transactions for properties in excess of $4M has actually gone up year-over-year.  Indeed, the week of November 2-8 saw 45 contracts signed over $4M, with 14 contracts signed over $10M.  This was the strongest weekly luxury contract volume in 5 years.  We imagine that the roll-out of the tax has affected overall pied-a-terre demand and ownership, but it has not yet materialized into discernible trends on a macro level.

This is all still very preliminary and the jury is still out.  With the benefit of a broad clientele of buyers and sellers navigating the upper echelons of the NYC real estate market, we have a unique boots-on-the-ground view of everything that is going on.  We are always available to discuss, so please do not hesitate to reach out!
Welcome Lindsey Skidmore! 
In October, we welcomed our newest agent, Lindsey Skidmore, to the team! Having grown up crisscrossing the country, with stops in Alabama, Texas, Michigan, and Tennessee, Lindsey has finally found her way home to NYC. And she’s certainly earned her New Yorker credentials! Having called no fewer than 11 neighborhoods home—including Gramercy, Midtown, the Lower East Side, Flatiron, Park Slope, Bushwick, Crown Heights, Flatbush, Harlem, the Upper East Side, and the Upper West Side—she has lived in more of New York than the rest of us combined! 

Lindsey will be working alongside Rebecca and Dan, so many of you will soon have the pleasure of meeting her. With her infectious smile, sunny personality, and enthusiasm, she’s already a wonderful addition to the Digs family. We’re delighted to have her on board!